The Review Hub - Page 11

G043R · 08-17-2008

Remember guys I'm trying to cut back on the list pile up... Its fine from now on I would rather take the map suggestions more spaced out I mean ...I told this to some of my few forging friends if you want some one to look at your map..take the time to look at others as well ... I know we all don't have the time but this is a two sided sword, help and we help... as for the maps both of them looked rather interesting .. Besides the fact that I am scared shitless on taking on Danger zone I'm willing to review this map... I'm going to ask though.. (only to review members only) How should we do single game mini games?

Bloumbas · 08-17-2008

I dont think you can just ask to have your reviews, if it does well on its original post, odds are it will be checked out. If everyone could just ask, the hub would be over their heads in maps. Maybe recommendations of oters maps, but not your own, or at least I dont think so. I'll delete ifI I'm wrong.

E93 · 08-17-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by DimmestBread

EDIT: E93, I'm not sure if this is just me but the links to all of those maps that are getting reviewed aren't working for me. Just thought i'd tell you.

Thanks for letting me know. I copied it, and changed some things from the old Review Hub thread in Off-Topic. So maybe that's why...
I'll have the links updated and changed to be working properly by tommorow.

Quote:

Originally Posted by G043R

(only to review members only) How should we do single game mini games?

I think we should do it like any other map. We'll just specify on his gametype.

I myself have a question now:
Do you think we should start anew on the Maps to be Reviewed List?
It's pretty obvious most of the members that are supposed to review some of those maps, won't. Maybe, we should just Start a new List, with completely new maps. Most of those are maps from May.
Should we start accepting to do reviews for people?
What do you members think?

G043R · 08-17-2008

For E93 I'm for taking some Suggestions not a forced list... because I think what happed in the old list ...people would come by do a review and then simply post there map expecting to get a review ..and it ended up totally one siding the reviews ..(meaning only the people that reviewed ever got there maps reviewed..)

Now as Yellow has been talking about the idea is review maps you like ..not what your told to do... because maps you don't like to look at ...your not going to play well on..so simply put don't let some one force you to review...

Now on to map to review List... I'm going to state from now on there is no list ... You review what you want... The list only got started because people keep suggesting maps and I think the reviewers didn't want to do one or some of the maps... so I mean what good was the list? The only real list we should have is a positive map list of people who have said they are going to review something and maybe a deadline of when to post it by..(thinking of the dead line as an IF only if you guys want it...)

This in turn will limit build up of maps and you can't spam the thread with suggested maps any more... its only if a review want to review it that it says up here...

Now I have been thinking about Suggested maps as well...
I think some good reasoning would help... just a map link is almost advertisings but to explain why you think it should be reviewed is up to you ...I mean your not making much of a case for us to want to Review a map if your not taking the time to show us something worth our time... that goes for map makers in general..how you present your maps helps as well but ... thats why we take suggestions ... people can help any one else they see with a good map...

Rant over...

Thanks for all the suggestions guys.. but remember don't over do it... or I will take that rule out.

(crap for got the mini game stuff)
lol ... Well I personally think for Dangerzones case we could judge him on most of review sections... but if the case arises I think we could go for on case bases...

The Yellow · 08-17-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by G043R

For E93 I'm for taking some Suggestions not a forced list... because I think what happed in the old list ...people would come by do a review and then simply post there map expecting to get a review ..and it ended up totally one siding the reviews ..(meaning only the people that reviewed ever got there maps reviewed..)

Now as Yellow has been talking about the idea is review maps you like ..not what your told to do... because maps you don't like to look at ...your not going to play well on..so simply put don't let some one force you to review...

Now on to map to review List... I'm going to state from now on there is no list ... You review what you want... The list only got started because people keep suggesting maps and I think the reviewers didn't want to do one or some of the maps... so I mean what good was the list? The only real list we should have is a positive map list of people who have said they are going to review something and maybe a deadline of when to post it by..(thinking of the dead line as an IF only if you guys want it...)

This in turn will limit build up of maps and you can't spam the thread with suggested maps any more... its only if a review want to review it that it says up here...

Now I have been thinking about Suggested maps as well...
I think some good reasoning would help... just a map link is almost advertisings but to explain why you think it should be reviewed is up to you ...I mean your not making much of a case for us to want to Review a map if your not taking the time to show us something worth our time... that goes for map makers in general..how you present your maps helps as well but ... thats why we take suggestions ... people can help any one else they see with a good map...

Rant over...

Thanks for all the suggestions guys.. but remember don't over do it... or I will take that rule out.

(crap for got the mini game stuff)
lol ... Well I personally think for Dangerzones case we could judge him on most of review sections... but if the case arises I think we could go for on case bases...

Ohhhhh yeaaaaah. See that, as I said. Lol.

E93 · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by G043R

Now I have been thinking about Suggested maps as well...
I think some good reasoning would help... just a map link is almost advertisings but to explain why you think it should be reviewed is up to you ...I mean your not making much of a case for us to want to Review a map if your not taking the time to show us something worth our time... that goes for map makers in general..how you present your maps helps as well but ... thats why we take suggestions ... people can help any one else they see with a good map...

That should be edited, made formal, and then edited onto the first post. Then, it'd be much better.

About the List:
I just have one question: Where should we get our maps from, should we just search and roam the Map Forums, in search for a good one, or one we'd like to review? Or should we just still allow suggestions?
There could be a list like:

MAPS TO BE REVIEWED
blbalblablalbalbalbal by blablablablalbal
blablablablalbalb by blablalbalbl

MAPS UP FOR GRABS
amasslakjjf
fkslajdlskdfjalskjf
lsldakjlksdaj
laksjfkl - sdafjlkja

Know what I mean? Then we could just take maps from the Grabs section, but it wouldn't be neccessary. And if after a week, or a month, and no one had grabbed it, I'd remove it from the list.
What do you think?

G043R · 08-18-2008

as for maps up for grabs you can keep a list but I am not going to keep up with it... thats all you man... and if we are all agreed i will up date the first post

Bloumbas · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by E93

That should be edited, made formal, and then edited onto the first post. Then, it'd be much better.

About the List:
I just have one question: Where should we get our maps from, should we just search and roam the Map Forums, in search for a good one, or one we'd like to review? Or should we just still allow suggestions?
There could be a list like:

MAPS TO BE REVIEWED
blbalblablalbalbalbal by blablablablalbal
blablablablalbalb by blablalbalbl

MAPS UP FOR GRABS
amasslakjjf
fkslajdlskdfjalskjf
lsldakjlksdaj
laksjfkl - sdafjlkja

Know what I mean? Then we could just take maps from the Grabs section, but it wouldn't be neccessary. And if after a week, or a month, and no one had grabbed it, I'd remove it from the list.
What do you think?

ha you should get your maps from my sig haha. I'm glad review hub is bgetting started again, GO4ER you seem like your in charge haha. I think you guys are right, you should get to decide which maps are reviewed, because if you take suggestions from people about their own maps, like i said in my first sentance, then your gonna end up with some crappy maps, and people not liking their reviews, and some maps would get like a 1/10 and your review would be like you fail, this map fails, and everything you do fails. When you ever do review maps, hit me up, twas a fun game last time.

Shihuru · 08-20-2008

Hey guys, you think you can review map Shihuruville maps, don't review the first shihuruville if you decided your going to review them, i have to post the remake first...

E93 · 08-20-2008

Link Shihuru?

OK guys, time has passed, and I decided to partially keep the list.
I ''cleaned'' it up, so now, we have a completely new list.
For those members and non-members who didn't catch the last conversations here, if you decide to reccomend a map, I will put it up on the Up For Grabs List. Note that we might not want to review your map, and that's just something you'll have to deal with.

The list so far is as follows:
V TO BE REVIEWED V
Danger Zone To be Reviewed by G043R

V NEW ADDITIONS V
Warlot
Bad Posture

Once we get enough maps on the To be Reviewed List, I'll schedule us a Review date