not sure just WHAT to think of this map
I saw this map quite a while back on it's original post. Needless to say, I was thoroughly impressed by the stunning screen shots in the post and immediately downloaded. Upon my first playthrough, however, I was thoroughly unimpressed, and immediately deleted to conserve hard drive space. Lo and behold, today I log onto ForgeHub to see this very same map, which I had so hastily deleted just days ago, gracing the top of the front page!
How can this be? - I thought - Surely there is something special that I missed the first time around! So I Que'd for Download once again, to re-inspect and seriously review this map that had previously dropped right off my radar. Here is what I've concluded.
I usually love these "Ancient Maps," for one because I love Tomb Raider (I love you Lara!), and two, because the architecture reverberates more of what the "true" forerunner feel is to me. (ex - Halo 2's Sanctuary.) However, this map felt more to me like a combination of two great things that, when combined, loose their best qualities.
1. Halo 2's Warlock - a great map with annoying symmetry.
2. The crawling tunnels in The Legend of Zelda, Windwaker - a great game with this annoying type of puzzle.
As a total noob myself, I naturally fell victim to the teleporter traps, wasted my grenades, and couldn't get out. For anyone playing it for the first time, especially against people who know exactly how it works, it will get really irritating really fast. It was not until I dissected the map in forge that I realized what a sickeningly triumphant piece of master-forging it really is. The precision, the geometry, the aesthetics - it's all so damned clever, but I just can't accept this map for anything more than that. Aesthetics. It is neither groundbreaking, nor flowing, nor even self-distinguishing.
What I want is a map that I can just look at the name and its base Foundry backdrop and instantly think "Hey, I remember this map! It's that ____ map! The one with the really cool _____!" Don't feel bad, though - I'm obviously asking far too much from any forger.
This map is a hands-down 10/10. Nevertheless, upon posting this review, I plan to re-erase Temple of Atlas (sorry), but now with a greater appreciation for what makes it feature-worthy material.
"We've found something so hot that they're scrambling over each other just to get their filthy claws on it -- but I don't care if it's God's own personal anti-son-of-a-bitch machine or just a damned hula hoop. If the Covenant want it, we ain't gonna let 'em have it. What we will let them have is a gut full of lead and a pool of their own blood to drown in!"
- Sgt. Johnson, Halo CE
|