Quote:
Originally Posted by Foxxeh Squirrel
...If you want to make this map better than it already is, which is kinda good,.... 3/5 for now, mainly because of originality.
|
People like you are what's making this site go to shit. You get people who post a terrible map, and instead of telling them the truth and why its bad, people will just beat around the bush and not give criticism and be straightforward and say THIS IS BAD, AND THIS IS WHY:
why are people so afraid to actually tell people the truth. That's why you post a map, to get criticism on what you did wrong and try to improve your forging. [/rant]
My review:
THIS SUCKS AND THIS IS WHY:
-You have no attempt to make the map decent looking and/or eye-appealing.
-The map shows no real idea of flow for gameplay.
-Cluttered messes of weapons/ objects are always a bad idea.
-Too many power-ups for the size of the map.
-There are no nice smooth transitions between parts of the map, everything is just a random thrown together cluttered mess.
Now anroma, this post is not personal in anyway. I am sick of people not giving actual feedback to help people improve their forging. If you don't correct a problem, people think it's ok to continue since to them there was nothing wrong. That in turn leads to more people posting more and more shitty maps and again people afraid to be real. And eventually, the problem becomes so big, it ruins the entire site and what FH was meant to be in the first place,
which is for users to share their creations, and get constructive feedback. Constructive feedback means that they can use the input they got from another user and
build upon that to
improve.
I hope to set a precendent for whoever reads this post to keep in mind
so what about post counts. That's not what the site is about. Give a real review in a post for the creator to use to improve their forging and make better maps, not just post for the sake of posting and in turn hurt the site.